Interview with Burak Delier

art-ist, Contemporary Art Series-15 Artist Book-6, 2013

Güncel Sanat Dizisi-15 Sanatçı Kitabı-6, Burak Delier: Displacing Silence, 2013

PINAR ÖĞRENCİ: The video work titled Crisis and Control, shows a group of people from different business sectors and positions coming together in an office space, practicing yoga in their work uniforms while simultaneously talking in business jargon. The conversations are focused on the problems of working life, issues of career planning and anxieties about the future. How did this video come into being and how did you choose the people who performed in it?

BURAK DELİER:

I have been involved in questioning the working conditions, the ways workers establish relationships with their jobs and with their bodies for a remarkably long time. One of my early works, in 2001, Untitled (White Collar Employees Series) was also about white-collar workers. Of course, the themes of work, labor and liberation have always been significant to me; however, today, considering the post-Fordist, flexible working conditions and life-style imposed by neoliberalism, these themes emerge as vital issues that need to be focused on. Nowadays, ‘job and career’ and ‘liberation and self-realization’ are perceived as almost identical. Yet, in the past, working was considered identical to slavery and alienation. Thus, the crisis emerges; a process operating by means of daily life practices as a result new forms of subjectivity appear.

The main point that draws my attention in the ‘yoga practice’ is that it has a modus operandi that appears paradoxical at first sight: reaching a meditative state, inner peace then freedom through maintaining ones balance in a difficult position that requires endurance and strength. I mean, one can’t acquire inner peace and freedom comfortably; on the contrary, an opening is acquired at a borderline state, by means of maintaining bodily control through endeavor, virtuosity and discipline. An expansion is acquired by reaching a challenging goal, introspection at that difficult borderline state; and the knowledge of perceiving life, body, mind from a different standpoint is obtained.

The “performers” on the Crisis and Control video are not professional actors or actresses portraying white-collar workers of the business life; they are real life white-collar workers from real business life practicing yoga. The identities they play are based on the expression of their own experiences. Perhaps, from time to time, their business personae speak for themselves. In this respect, the video is comprised of the characteristics of a “documentary film”. However, it is also an effort to record a “performance” -locating the discourses about the business world and private life into a compelling yoga position. All the conversations used in Crisis and Controlare dialogues recorded during the yoga practice. No other audio recording is done. We see a yoga session being practiced in an office space rather than a yoga hall. Hence the sense of outlandishness. On the other hand, yoga and pilates halls are typically located both in or near plazas. So, in terms of the location setup, disputes and concurrences exist together. Almongst other issues, the video attempts to make people think about these concurrences and the disputes between these two spaces.

PÖ: It is commonly thought that the human body and mind, suffering from stressful working conditions as part of the system, are rehabilitated and restored through yoga practice. In Crisis and Control, a very personal activity normally performed during leisure time is injected into an institutional structure, the office space. It is as if you are redefining the space and the objects in it. The bodies practicing yoga that we see, are in ironed business attire, ties or high-heeled shoes rather than in regular yoga outfits. The resistance of the bodies, as it were, is tested. Could we assert that -via the speeches in the form of outpourings- while the office space is being transformed into a kind of therapy and recovery area, the body is discovering its diverse potential within the space it inhabits?

BD: Personally, I think that this video displays a prolonged moment of prevalent crisis. By making the performers speak, I make them avoid focusing on their inner worlds. Perhaps, this act evokes the relationship between torture and truth. A torture session, is aimed at breaking the resistance of the person, both physically and psychologically, to extract the truth. Crisis and Control doesn’t directly aim at extracting the truth, but, as a whole, it indicates an actuality: We see that this specific crisis has an actual palpable existence in our daily life. The performers appear calm, confident and restrained, as if nothing is abnormal, but we can foresee that they will surrender soon. I highlight not the moment of surrender, but the moments of prolonged endurance.

If this video is pointing to a potential, it is the potential that everyone uses and struggles to acquire: it is the potential of emancipation under torture by avoiding confrontation.

I merely entwine the compensation space (yoga) with the space that is considered to be the source of the illness (office – working). I am asking if it is possible to escape such a life (the specific culture of the relationship between work and emancipation, which substantially arises from neoliberalism) by improving our talents, mastering, improving ourselves and becoming more successful.

PÖ: Speaking of the need to redefine the space, one of your early works titled ‘We were writing while you are at sleep’ (1999-2000) comes to mind. Your starting point was to explore the marks, imprints and writings that the street children and homeless people leave on public spaces, like walls and roads at night. How can we interpret this work of public space, in the context of the intervention by street artists, skateboarders, or as is specific in your work, homeless people? This is also directly related to the Gezi Resistance…

BD: You made an appropriate and interesting connection. Following the Gezi Park protests, this is relevant especially today; both in the context of slogans with their sui generis dynamism (subjective, humorous, personal, discarding the existing political terminology and thus pointing to the possibility of a different kind of politics) and in the context of Gezi Park protests as a spatial occupation movement. The work titled “We were writing while you are at sleep” is based on research for an exhibition at  the university.  I walked around the places where homeless people stay in İstanbul and documented their processes of inscribing and making the space their own. I created a file full of photo collages that reveal the relationship between the inscriptions and the spaces. Afterwards, I selected one of those inscriptions to make a sticker, and for one week, applied it to the walls of places where I hung about and documented this process. In a way, I marked my spaces/areas/roads. Homeless people and street children don’t come out and occupy the city centers, they just settle in gaps, the interspaces. However, Gezi Park Resistance was unequivocally the movement of taking back (the public space). Taking back the space from the capital and the state. Gezi Park Resistance represents the people coming out of their cells and opening an area for themselves. They are creating a moment of subjectivity beyond the working and leisure time by stepping on public spaces, resisting, going home and occasionally to work.

PÖ: The mobile workshop “Another Architecture is Possible” (2010) that you executed for Gülensu-Gülsuyu Shop, the S.T.ARGEM (Street Collectors Research and Development Center, 2009) is a project you co-founded with  Museum of the Third City (2009), reveals your interest and belief in collective work. We also see that you are creating process-based projects while working with different segments of society. Can we say that you prioritize the process and communication, rather than the story or the agent?

BD: In retrospect, the projects that I devoted maximum time and labor to, are S.T.ARGEM. and Museum of the Third City. Frankly, both of them were very difficult to overcome without any support of an institution. In S.T.ARGEM., I worked with sociologist Eylem Akçay and artist Güneş Terkol. It was an educational process for all of us. The realization, preparation and pre-research process of the project took one year. We hadn’t decided exactly what to do before the execution period; everything was designed as an open-ended and mutual learning process. We tried to form a “negotiation” style developed from the ground up, by excluding approaches like “helping”, “supporting”, “social responsibility” that create hierarchical relations, in addition to the intentions of “restoration of communication” that dominate the art world and wanted an easiness of just generating knowledge. S.T.ARGEM. was mainly aiming at imagining alternative ways of communicating and gaining experiences; not at improving the situation of the street collectors. At that time, we decided not to have a concrete product or have information as the final outcome of the Project S.T.ARGEM. and planned to set up the shop as a space for active experience and self-transformation., and we did it.

PÖ: In Museum of the Third City for instance, you came together with refugees and immigrants and asked them to describe the villages, neighborhoods and houses that they were forced to leave; then you made drawings of these places together. In these utterly primative/historic drawings, it seemed as if every image and trace was pointing to an absence.

How do you describe these pale traces in the context of the shadowed truth of boundaries, the concept of deterritorialization, and of not belonging? 

BD: In The Museum of the Third City, the thing we did was to remember together (with Ozge Genc). We were trying to remember the places, objects, skies and the lands that we had never seen before through the directives of the refugees and immigrants. They were trying to reconstitute the places they had seen ages ago from their memories. The figures were faint, ambiguous and quite objective; the colors as well. When you asked them about the color of the sky, shapes of the leaves and forms of the mountains, peculiar challenges arose. In this work, the drawings and colors are not necessarily objective; rather, the participants are taking refuge in objectivity because they are trying to reproduce the memory of the other. Naturally, we weren’t able to draw the images in their minds and they probably weren’t able to remember the places properly either. However, thanks to our efforts, we created a third kind of tool that could be called “performative memory” or “performative archive”. The project questioned critical themes such as memory, history, remembrance, reinterpretation and archiving while trying to reach to a seemingly impossible goal.

PÖ: At this point, I would like to add something else: Your known works are commonly associated with concepts of social violence, capitalism, the capital and arts market while your questioning of issues of private and public space seems to be neglected. For example, in the “Meeting” video of “Tersyön Feasibility Research”, you have focused on the theme of monitoring by using a glass focus group room in which people can be seen from the outside, but cannot see out of.

BD: In the video titled “Meeting”, professionals of the business world are put in a position of being monitored and watched, so their usual positions as observers and watchers are reversed as they are located on the other side of the room. Furthermore, the audience takes the surveillance position which is normally assumed by the business world.

“We Will Win” (2010), the project I did with Kontratak, “Zapturapt” (2009) and “Art Facts” the project which was realized in Salt in 2012, were experiments of intervening space, in which the meeting of the board of directors was broadcasted live in the Açık Sinema (Open Cinema) which was the foremost public space of the arts institution. From this standpoint, there emerges the rich possibility of questioning the organization about institutional or urban functioning through the issue of space.

It is evident that some of these works have a subversive method. For instance, “Zapturapt” realizes a small and ironic privatization from below, as opposed to the brutal privatization and reshaping of the urban space from above which is done according to the necessities of the capital and the subjective models offered to us. This is a personal, small-scale occupation which can be ended if a municipality officer removes the cover…

PÖ: You are also discussing the issues of risk taking, winning and losing in the video titled “The Deal” (2013). There was an agreement between the artist and the art patron in your work titled Collector’s Wish. This time, you are creating a connection between (besides the artist and collector) the bank, financial sector, trader and gallery; can you tell me about this?

BD: As you know, following the recent crisis in Europe, both the market and the collectors began to be more influential in the art world. The market became very strongly antipathetic toward public institutions. In Turkey’s case, the collectors and strong families came into existence from the very beginning. The discourse they use generally includes terms like ‘opening up space for arts’ and ‘supporting’. Here, I open a space for the collector and try to eliminate myself. I am made up of merely a hand. While the one who sets up the stage is the artist, the one who exhibits a specific talent and subjectivity is the collector/art patron. In this replacement game, I see a potential of emancipation; not by aiming at being appreciated, not by revealing the subjectivity but by changing the fundamental operational rules of the game.

For “The Deal”, I just formed the framework. In the process of forming the content, I took part indirectly. The concept of risk is the core of this work. I previously heard from the refugees that there existed methods of bypassing the banking system. If you wanted to send money to your family living in Africa, you would give the money to a friend of yours living here and they would ask their family living in Africa to give the equivalent amount to your family. The money isn’t circulated, but the transfer is realized. In this way, family relationships, which are based on trust, are bypassing the banking system.  Another example is, when a person who can’t get a credit card is given one by a family member. Here, we witness the world of “low” finance, not of  high finance involving transactions of large sums of money and the macro economic issues. Here, we see the methods of the little man facing the giant and an incomprehensible system. What I am trying to do is to manipulate the system from below, through art. Taking some capital out of the currency and using it in another game. I make an autonomous/arbitrary play which isn’t dependant on any labor theory of value, which disregards the economy of emotions and moral economy that was created by the credit and debt system (the obligation of the borrower to pay their debt –with an interest rate that is claimed to be very rational according to the rules of the science of economy).

PÖ: Can we interpret this work in context of the difficulties of producing a work of art and the precarity of the artist?

BD: This work also stemmed from the absence of a strong foundation for the arts in Turkey. You know, protective and supportive funds and bursary for the arts are scarce here in Turkey. First, the artist makes the production, if the work draws attention and is marketable; he sells the work in the market and hopes to survive this way. First, he spends money to produce, then waits for return. It is an extremely primitive business model! To survive in ambiguous conditions and against the grinding machine of the market, unsupported and precariat the artist tries to seduce the audience and the arts community. I start off with this delicate and defenseless position. In the absence of an infrastructure, the artist remains face to face with banking procedures and credit system. He has to convince the gallery he is affiliated with, to get bank credit. However, if he doesn’t produce any concrete work with this bank credit, he then finds an unemployed trader and together they start to play a game that will result in an ex parte situation. It is a game prevailling only by a little chance, fate, labor, talent, intellect and too much tension, stress and ambiguity. In this sense, it resembles art! If the trader makes a gain above the credit’s expenses and bank interests of 18 months credit within a month, only through speculation, he takes all the money, including the  principal. If he cannot gain that amount, the artist takes the money. In any case, it ends up with an artwork being offered to the market and valued by the ambiguous mechanisms of the art market. The artwork is produced during this process which is operating without anything concrete, merely circulating money and triggering a desire. There is no content as we know it. The content is the capital, the circulation of the capital in the stock market and the virtual environment. The same content turns out to be an artwork and is appreciated in the market. We see that both of the processes –financial and artistic market processes- create a nominal value without any concrete product just by triggering the desire. Facing the stock market fluctuations, the Trader needs to have a profit of 19% within one month. Even if 1 penny is short, he will lose all the money; all that stress over nothing. The artist, on the other hand, has to wait to confront the art market. Both of these people are unable to control these mechanisms. However, due to having the knowledge and talent, they try their chances.

During this process, the money in circulation is credit; money borrowed from the bank. Let me add that the gallery is going to sell the first edition of the work for just the total amount of the bank credit, the expenses and the interest. As an artist, I am not going to get the share that I would normally have, because, I have already taken the money, prior to producing the work. When the gallery sells the first edition of the work for the amount that equals the total expenses of the bank credit and the interest sum, it will neither win nor lose any money. A work will be realized at no cost. The artist is gambling with money that he hasn’t earned yet, but maybe will earn in the future.  At the end of the game, it is possible that he will earn, but it will not be a big deal. The important thing is that, thanks to the credit system, the future is brought to the present, and the hope expected to be realized, is marketed today and perceived to already have been realized. Considering a credit for 18 months, that covers the interest and all other charges in the stock market in just one month emphasizes the issues of time and money. After deserving the credit, I would prefer to make a more rational and risk free deal with the trader to guarantee the money. But this time, I would have preferred to have made a plain and simple business agreement with the trader and that would be to construct a determinable world in which the chance and fate can be controlled. However, we don’t live in such a world…

PÖ: This brings to mind Dostoyevsky’s character, Alexei Ivanovic in Gambler, who passionately gambles with almost no money. And of course, all the other characters who are waiting for the death of the grandmother, although there is no inheritance awaiting them… Similarly, in your work, The Deal, you are gambling with money that doesn’t belong to you. How does it feel to get involved in the stock market –which is an upper-middle class habit- as an artist? 

BD: I know that the words like “stock market”, “money” and “trader” generally have connotations related with “evil” and parasitism. But. this is not what it looks like, especially for us. In the worst case scenario, we are insignificant adventurers who seek for a moment to manipulate the system from below.  We may imagine that we will face a disaster at the end. However, it is no more than a prediction and we are still pursuing the possibilities of a mobile scenario. In the game I construct, we grab some money from the flow and place it in another game; it is a game in which rules are determined by the trader and me, in which I am taunting you with the idea of money -the basic problem of everyone in daily life. It’s great that it reminded you of the novel Gambler! Just as I said, if I could make a proper deal and a wise investment, I would be behaving like the German character who was openly criticized by and subjected to the hatred of Dostoyevsky because of the way he tried to calculate everything. In my opinion, the German character in the novel, even though this is gambling, tries to systematize the fate by involving a risk reduction method, a system, the intellect and the calculation of probabilities. This character represents the subversion of the tradition of the old world and declares the reign of the modern and rational one, the one of calculation. However, our Eastern character is playing the gamble passionately. Even though he could win big money in one night, equally so, he can lose everything in one game. In a sense, he is playing with fate. He wants to welcome the fate. I think we should also remember the character of the older lady in the novel who didn’t calculate anything and at the same time, didn’t lose money; she consciously decided when to play and when to leave it. It seems as if she was symbolizing a different kind of intellect and wisdom beyond the duality of West and East that was formed stereotypically by Dostoyevsky.

By the way, the trader’s labor belongs to an interesting category of labor. Just like the gambler, he is playing his own game by trying to estimate the ambiguous orientation of the currency and the development of positions by looking at the blinking lights in the monitor. At the same time, he sits at the table like an office worker and “works” with a computer. When I talked to Altay (the trader) –he is a ” youngster” from so-called 90’s generation- he said that he preferred not to work for a financial organization. He rather prefered to make a living by discovering fraud in the stock market and in the system underhandedly. As I see it, he is pursuing the feeling of pleasure in tricking the system and aiming to be more intelligent and talented -just like the gambler who has beaten fate and brought it to heel. Working means surrendering and being enslaved. But of course, (just like artists) avoiding work, not being a slave of wage, produces an engulfment that the ‘self’ is absorbed in: where you cannot keep your distance from working and passions and spend much more time and effort, again like the gambler.  At this point, there starts a process exceeding the borders of the “labor” and covering all other truths. You are the one who is responsible for everything. Yet, it is wiser to lose your wage instead of losing your spirit as the company has gone bankrupt.

PÖ: In your work titled “Hommage à Balotelli’s Missed Trick”, while of African origin, Italian football player Balotelli is about to make a score, he throws the ball out by a dribble past. By ignoring the expectations both of the audience and of the team players, he is taking a quite personal decision and risks the play. As if he wants to throw a spanner in the works… The work is in harmony with the other works in the exhibition considering the terms of career, success, body, risk and game. Can you tell us the story of how you got involved in the exhibition?

BD: Balotelli is an extremely talented, handsome, strong and popular football player. Normally, he makes spectacular movements and is able to make shots at the goal from difficult positions. But here, even though he had an obvious scoring chance, suddenly he gave up and kicked the ball out with a reckless back-heel move. I tried to understand the meaning of this move for long time. What attracted me to this move? Then, I saw a short documentary on Balotelli titled  “Waste of Talent” and slowly came to realize that kicking that goal is a burden, it is almost derogatory of him. If one kicks a goal very easily, it has no meaning beyond doing what people want him to do. In fact, I think that, Balotelli tries to seek for some meaning and to think beyond his duty to find an openness that allows him to put his signature to. He tries to succeed at something challenging and beautiful. I feel like here exists the core of a strike or a refusal to work. They generally talk about the beauty of the game etc. in the football industry, but as you see, football is becoming more and more connected to physics, it is systemized and rendered to a pre-determined state. Balotelli does an unexpected thing here by putting his talent aside. Of course, you are right, it is quite a hazardous act for his career; no football team wants a scorer who scores at his own sweet will. I see a subjectification here as well. For example, I always think that when bio-mechanic stars like Messi and Ronaldo celebrate their scores, the thing they celebrate is just their own slavery. They satisfied the expectations and are now celebrating, but Balotelli feels the insulting side of meeting the expectations and rejects it. He either never satisfies and rejects it or meets it in a kind of way that goes beyond the expectation. There is no ‘in-between’, the ‘in-between’ is slavery…

Honestly, I dwelt on Balotelli’s attitude for a long time and afterwards, I realized that this attitude had connections with the “trader” in “The Deal”, more meaningfully, with my art practice. During this thinking process, it dawned on me that, like him, I didn’t want to make or achieve anything pre-determined and have it become an obligation. I prefer throwing the ball out at the very moment that the audience is waiting to applaud, rather than putting the ball straight into the net. It is rather like Bartleby’s motto, “I would prefer not to”. Balotelli also has a similar preference. We “prefer not to do” this or that but, it prompts us to do more difficult, intense, risky and sometimes sillier and daring things. We don’t just aim at scoring a goal, producing a work of art or making money; we are seeking ways to manipulate the game and forming a new one, not to play the existing one. We are chasing a subjectivity through difficult and indirect ways and of course for basic pleasure…

PÖ I am thinking about the Performance of Silence from the very first day. It may not be that its attractiveness is merely in its secrecy… In an environment where everything becomes accessible and usable, attending exhibitions or performances and reaching for its visual documents by using social media are very easy; you on the contrary, make an agreement promising that you will not show or talk about anything. Can we view this performance as a kind of rejection or realization of the ‘self-censor’?

BD: I guess, in this work, my tendency to look awry at the idea of freedom shows up again. Is it possible to be liberated through not talking, not sharing or not transmitting? If that’s possible, isn’t it necessary then to reconsider talking and free speech coded as being liberatory?

We should also be reminded that the motivation to produce is triggered through the existing works of art. However, its actual place of realization are the places of sharing, discussing and transferring. Essentially, the moment when the work is seen and heard; it is the moment of reflection and resonance. In this respect, the production of an artwork is realized through transference, interpretation, reproduction and by mythologizing and making a story of it by exchanging it between blogs, twitter accounts, periodicals and writings. If you aim at realizing a “strike” in the arts field, the factory which you need to stop is this machine. Through the Silenceperformance, I tried to create an island of silence in this very talkative factory of the art world and imagined a new form of subjectivity through silence. Those people who attended the presentation were promising to realize this strike performance. However, in the case of a violation of the contract, no sanction would be imposed. As long as they want and believe in it, the performance would continue. I intended to establish a trusting relationship with no personal gain or any expectance of it.

As far as I know, the performance still continues…