Symbolic Meaning of Architecture and Gezi Park Resistance

Arkitera, June, 2013

Text by Pınar Öğrenci

The Gezi Park Resistance offers a good opportunity for us to think about the symbolic meaning of architecture.

That architecture has mediated such a large social action has shown all of us that this profession, known mostly as the activity of building and creating form, is in fact more an activity of “giving form to a process.” All of us now know better that the current government uses the architectural profession as a tool to create a so-called atmosphere of abundance through construction and the rent economy, and to carry out its project of Islamizing the cities. Architecture is one of the lifelines of the “form” of the new life it wants to create.

Gezi Park served as a mirror for both the protesters and the government. We can say that this mirror reflected, on the one hand, the government’s backward-looking, insistent imposition of reconstruction and its authoritarian, uncompromising understanding of central rule; and on the other hand, the world, charged with potential, of the incredible resistance the people showed against this imposition. What kind of contradiction is it for a government to fight militarism, put coup supporters on trial and make a move toward resolving the Kurdish people’s years-long demand for peace, while insisting on the reconstruction, whatever it takes, of an old “barracks” building that belongs to the military, a building whose function is not even settled yet (one day said to become a shopping mall, another day a hotel or a museum)? Besides its symbolic importance, what kind of rent value does the reconstruction of the old Topçu Barracks have, that it has led to a crisis of violence lasting weeks before the eyes of the whole world? The government shows such ignorance of architectural history that it believes an Orientalist building is nothing more than Ottoman architectural eclecticism. The Orientalist movement emerged mostly among Western architects, from a prejudiced and formalist view of an unquestioned “Eastern architecture,” and it mostly includes Indian, Russian and Maghrebi architectural styles. If Orientalism consisted only of Ottoman and Seljuk architecture, a movement like the First National Style would not have appeared right after it. Orientalism is colonialism embodied in architecture; this being the case, to claim an Orientalist building as “Ottoman architecture” and so on is a pointless exercise. The government regards the reconstruction of the Topçu Barracks, which it identifies with the 31 March Incident, as a tool of political retaliation. A similar attitude is not hard to see in the project to turn Yassıada, identified with Menderes, into a congress island. If the government has had any success, it is that it has made a building that does not exist engraved in memory more strongly than its physical presence ever could. The Topçu Barracks exists more strongly than before, but as a symbol of the people’s resistance against its construction and of the unbelievable violence used by the police… The Gezi Park protesters showed the whole world that the real owner of this site, which once hosted soldiers, is today the people, and that this is not the age of cannons and rifles, but a time of reason, humanity and solidarity.

During the resistance, the inside of Taksim Square turned outside, with all its organs… The construction containers set up as part of the pedestrianization project, which was launched despite all objections, were occupied, and the contractor company’s papers were scattered across the ground. After the construction hoardings that hid what was going on behind them were removed, the excavation sites we could not see were exposed, and we reached the square by stepping over construction materials. The walls of domination that the central government had built in cooperation with contractors were razed to the ground. It turned out that the renovation of the Atatürk Cultural Center, which we had thought was under way and which had turned into a never-ending story, had hardly begun. It became clear that the reason behind the construction’s extremely slow progress was the government’s insistence that it be demolished, and this even though the building has a protection order!

It was claimed that the trees in Gezi Park would be uprooted and replanted elsewhere… Those trees were not uprooted. Construction vehicles savagely dug up the soil beneath the trees and toppled them to the ground with their roots, to serve as firewood. Does the uprooting of these trees not parallel the displacement of all the peoples who have taken root in this land and once lived here in peace? First, to dig out the ground from underneath through all sorts of political games, and then to uproot! In this sense, Gezi Park became a place, in a multicultural city like Istanbul, where differences between people, such as class, gender and ethnic origin, could be in contact and at peace rather than closed off and separated. For the people of Istanbul, Gezi Park is a “threshold” space for claiming shared spaces, making one’s voice heard collectively, and creating a fresh culture of resistance by turning differences into an advantage. The people of Istanbul crossed this threshold by taking a step from their homes to the squares, in other words from private space to public space.

Gezi Park will go down in history as a point of “kindness,” reminding city dwellers who look for a footing in a chaotically growing city of humanity and solidarity. Among the protesters I talked to were many who said they felt very good there, that no trace of their depression remained, or that they slept in Gezi Park because they had no real home to go to… Small and large groups from different parts of the city came together, set up tents, kept watch in Gezi Park, and created a collective space where they felt at home. The image of the “tent,” which today is generally identified with nomadic groups, is important, since, as the simplest “house” construction in the history of architecture, it recalls the idea of “returning to the nest.” In Istanbul, a city of migrants, many people with different identities, and perhaps with all kinds of troubles in their own households, joined hands here and set out to redefine their own selves and shape their city. Almost everything a neighborhood should have came into being spontaneously in Gezi Park: tents, a market, food and drink service areas, a library, an infirmary, a talking platform, a volleyball court, and areas for dance, concerts and film screenings. These structures, built from temporary materials such as tarpaulin, rope, wooden crates or pallets, or from building materials such as wall and flooring elements, were important for questioning the idea of the fixed building and of spatiality, and for making light of the reality of the architectural structure. One of the most beautiful aspects of this new order was that money was not valid as a unit of exchange. In every sense, Gezi Park is a hybrid “play” area where city dwellers arranged a public space as they wished, and it recalls the open-ended, creative actions of the Situationists.

The theatricality created by the unmanageable mass of people in Taksim Square and Gezi Park made city dwellers, discovering their own limits and their potential for defense, come together for the same purpose every day as if performing a bodily ritual. The human body, which is constantly on the move in the city, took up residence and settled in Gezi Park. What brought them together was the idea that the large emerges from within the small. As Gaston Bachelard also notes, the small, however narrow its door, opens a world before us. The detail of a thing can be the sign of a new world, one that carries, like all other worlds, the essential qualities of greatness. A small detail, such as the cutting down of a few trees in the middle of a mega-city, can be the starting point of an action across Turkey. That the people took as their point of reference not a monumental building like the Topçu Barracks but a park and the trees in it expresses a longing for the “local” (mahal) and for becoming civil. The Gezi Park Resistance has reminded us that fields of memory are not limited to monumental architectural structures (a war memorial, a temple, a museum and so on). Local places such as a street, a park, a tiny shop, a pastry shop or a cinema are much stronger fields of memory for us ordinary city dwellers than monumental spaces. Seen from this angle, the loss of the Emek Cinema and the İnci Pastry Shop, both destroyed recently, is an important loss in the memory of the people of Istanbul. Gezi Park was not written into the class of things lost; it has been engraved in our memories as a “local” field of memory.

Today, the giant shopping malls and mega projects built in the middle of city centers define the object of urban desire. One of the useful results of the Gezi action is that it has opened consumer culture and shopping malls to debate. Shopping malls are places where individuals, without realizing it, are kept under the control of the system and those in power, and where their movements are determined in advance. They are designed as places where a person almost loses themselves, spends money involuntarily, and can spend the whole day. Security cameras, barcodes, electronic tags, lighting and wayfinding design, decorative elements and colors all serve this purpose. The government, which wants to create a human type that does not drink alcohol and reproduces prolifically, attempted to turn Taksim from an entertainment and culture center into a consumption center and to have any tree it wished cut down for this purpose; thanks to the Gezi Park Resistance, that attempt has been pushed back. Thanks to this resistance, projects such as Istanbul’s urban transformation processes and the people displaced by them, public buildings privatized and sold off, and bridge tenders have returned to the agenda, and the awareness that followed has spread to other cities too.

The resistance exposed people to “shock,” distracted them and almost stopped daily life. Although the people of Istanbul, who live at a superhuman speed, spilled into the streets and kept moving because of the resistance, they in fact slowed down by changing their daily routines and returned to a human pace of life. They had the chance to take an interest in what was going on around them and to make contact with other people. This slowing down is a direct cure for the illness of “forgetting.” The “Standing Man” action is important in this respect too, because one of the most important causes of the forgetfulness peculiar to modernity is excessive speed.

The Gezi Park Resistance is an “anti-construction” reaction to the meaninglessness of today’s shameless and expansionist idea of “building.” The resistance is a new subject of research and inspiration for urban sociologists, historians, architects, urban scientists, artists and others. Gezi Park is not only a place of “contention” for the right to the city and the defense of the urban commons; it is a place of “peace,” where the need to understand one another, to draw close, to love, and to show compassion and kindness came to light. Despite the extreme violence the government saw fit to inflict on the protesters, and despite the fact that it is still occupied by police today, it will remain a place of peace in our memories.