Scenarios of Promised Happiness

‘Vaat edilen Mutluluk Senaryoları’, XXI, November, 2023

Text by Pınar Öğrenci

“You can make it,” “you can be happy,” “the power is in you,” “just want it and believe,” “the universe will respond to your requests”…! Self-help books and life coaches often want us to believe these sentences. We must play our role well: hard work, concentration on the goal, motivation, absolute power and advanced career are the preconditions of happiness. But are “concentrating on the goal” and “advanced career” really preconditions for happiness, or are they a hidden part of the continuity of the system?

Almost the whole of Burak Delier’s latest exhibition consists of inverted conceptualizations of yoga and personal development. Yoga invites the body, which is kept under “control” through breathing exercises, to be released and to discover its hidden potentials in difficult positions. Personal development, on the other hand, draws a perspective in which the individual is in fact capable of achieving everything, and pumps up the belief that success and happiness are very close at hand. Delier’s video “Crisis and Control,” which consists of a yoga performance in an office environment, forms the backbone of the exhibition, and together with the other works attached to it, it takes up the questions of success, career and risk.

In the video “Crisis and Control,” performers doing yoga in pressed business clothes talk about the business worlds and career, using a business vocabulary that moves back and forth around the words of sales, success, energy, sector, project, tempo, brand and profitability. By dressing his performers in what could be called uncomfortable clothes, Delier practically tests their endurance. Bringing yoga into the office turns this place, the center of the system, into a kind of space of compensation or therapy.

That contemporary people’s need for self-realization and search for happiness coincide with success and career in working life in fact points to a contradiction. Delier draws a parallel between this contradiction and the way in which, in yoga, the body resists difficult positions for a long time and finally relaxes. The human body and soul in search of happiness are steered by “control” mechanisms within the neoliberal economic system. In a similar way, mental and physical health is seen not as a grace or gift of God, as in pre-modern times, but as one of the responsibilities that fall to the individual.

If you get stuck and fall into depression, don’t worry, the remedy is ready: if you have money, you consult a life coach, a kind of paid friendship; if you don’t, self-help books step in, and you recover. In the model of “flexible capitalism,” which signals a “softened” and made-bearable version of a rigid and ruthless economic model, remedies never run out…

In “Crisis and Control” we see the performers sometimes acting alone and independently, sometimes as a team, which recalls job advertisements: independent and leadership-minded, suited to teamwork… The success of the video lies in its very good use of visual codes. The body and the office environment that shapes it are in perfect harmony… We face a typical office environment decorated with cold lights, hard materials such as glass, metal and marble, and uniform gray furniture. The performers are dressed uniformly like the space: black trousers or skirts, white shirts, black shoes… It is clear that it was shot in a plaza or an office tower, and through the windows we see other plaza constructions rising. The visual elements of the work keep company with the photograph series “White Collars” (2001) and the photographic frames of the sculpture “Little Man” (2005).

With this exhibition, video as a medium stops being a tool for narrating a process and becomes the work itself; the choice of location and performers, roles, costume and editing enter the work. Considering the success of “Crisis and Control,” Burak Delier seems to be signaling that he will produce more video works in the future.

In Delier’s works that relate directly or indirectly to architecture, “space” is perceived as a kind of cage. In “Reverse Feasibility” (2011) it is a glass cage in which those inside can be watched from outside; in one of his older works, “Curtain 2” (2003), the house itself is a kind of cage that holds the dream of escaping far away on a sailboat; in “Silence Performance” (2013), the gallery space is a white secret box that hides the details of the performance with a contract; in “The Last General” (2010), it is a glass bell jar in which the soldier looking for a way out is visible in all his nakedness; in “Delivery” (2006), it is an iron cage, the shelter of monkeys waiting to receive a weapon handed to them from outside; and finally in “Crisis and Control,” it is the office as a kind of space of surveillance that resembles a prison… In most of the works, space appears as a hidden mechanism of power and control that shapes modern people and gives them their form, and whose conceptual roots we can find in M. Foucault’s thesis on heterotopia.

In an interview I did with him, Burak Delier said that he had watched over and over the scene in which Balotelli, the Italian footballer of African origin, in a position very close to scoring, kicked the ball out of play instead of into the goal, in order to understand why the scene kept nagging at his mind. The Balotelli sculpture “Hommage à Balotelli’s Missed Trick,” a projection of this scene that keeps going around in the artist’s head, loops on the bust in the exhibition space, this time in the small size we are used to see from TV and computer screens. There are serious parallels between this gesture of Balotelli, which pushed the fans’ tolerance to its limit and dashed their expectations, and Delier’s own attitude of creating risks for himself, setting up imaginary companies, making statistics and so on, wandering outside the familiar language of art production… Delier always runs to the difficult side of the work; it is as if he sets up obstacles for himself, such as traps, ditches and barriers, and then plays a kind of game, taking various risks to overcome them… In short, he kicks the ball of the easy goal out and waits for the hard goal… Industrial football as popular culture and an object of consumption, the recent objections in Brazil to footballers’ earnings and to the 2014 World Cup, the reactions to Istanbul’s candidacy for the 2020 Olympic Games, and the economic crisis in countries such as Italy, Spain and Greece give more meaning to the emphasis on Balotelli’s shocking move.

One of the works in the exhibition is “Agreement.” A loan taken from a bank through the gallery for the production of the work is handed over to a “trader.” If the trader grows this money within a month to above the amount calculated together with the cost of the 18-month credit, all the money stays with the trader; if it falls below, the artist wins. We recall Aleksey Ivanovich in Dostoevsky’s The Gambler, who gambles with almost no money; Delier too plays a kind of gamble with the loan he took from the bank. This work, which can also be read in the context of the difficulties of art production and the artist’s precarity, is a typical Burak Delier construction revolving around statistics, risk, games, contracts, the art market and so on.

While in “Crisis and Control” office workers talk about work and career while doing yoga, in “Notes from My Mobile Phone” Delier talks about his own work and career plans as an artist. When these two works are considered together, they take us to the workshop “Required Qualifications” (2011) in the artist’s first solo exhibition at Outlet. There Delier had drawn attention to the parallels between the practices and language of the business world and the art world; here, although the two works in the exhibition operate differently, they allow a similar reading.

The production of the works, their reception, the reactions, the tools used, expectations for the future as an artist, career, success and so on: “Notes from My Mobile Phone” is like a summary of the exhibition… Again Dostoevsky comes before us, this time with Notes from Underground, but with a few differences. In place of the sick, or sickness-obsessed, Raskolnikov, we have the artist Burak Delier, who stubbornly goes after social contradictions, whose mind is always busy like a researcher’s, and who produces experimental works. The time is the time of mobile phones, Facebook and Twitter, and the festives “above ground” are museums, galleries, institutions and sponsorships, the latest Istanbul Biennial that stirred debate, ever more numerous rival fairs, and an Istanbul art world that, with its young artists, keeps expanding and presents an ambiguous picture… Considering his mode of production, which relies largely on research and statistical processes, the imaginary companies he sets up, the contracts and so on, we perhaps cannot say that he is underground, but it seems possible to say that Delier is a traveler on an extraordinary path.

Delier, who has so far avoided subjective stories, here for the first time becomes the subject of the work. What we see is not a historical or narrative subjectivity, but a subjectification in the sense of questioning the artist’s identity. I mentioned above the matter of self-help and coaching; here Delier is, in a way, his own coach. But just as Raskolnikov sometimes criticizes himself and makes new decisions, Delier too does not seem to believe very much what he says… It is possible to read between the lines that, in “Crisis and Control,” he refuses to fall into the trap of the conditions that the system imposes on us “flexibly” (?) for the sake of career, success and the happiness finally promised, and that we accept of our own free will. In that case, we can say that the matter of subjectivity I just mentioned is a trap set up to create a kind of illusion.

Within a short time you feel the weight of a hidden theme in the exhibition: the need to speak. On the one hand, Delier records his voice and image by speaking into his mobile phone; on the other hand, he looks for potential listeners by giving art talks in public space. Why do people want to speak or write…? The history of literature and cinema is full of such characters who talk to themselves: Goethe’s Faust, Dostoevsky’s underground man Raskolnikov, Paul Auster’s August Brill, the Man in the Dark who tells himself stories, and so on… Most of these characters see themselves as witnesses of a history being written, and while living with this awareness, they perceive the world in constant contradiction, anxiety and dissolution. This situation generally sums up the tragedy of modern man. In Delier’s works we see not a storytelling or inward-looking attitude, but the attitude of an observer who tries to understand his time, goes on to new problems on top of contradictions, and at times dives into statistics like a researcher. This attitude of Delier, who gives “Art Talks” to the person on the street, should be evaluated together with his relation to writing, another mode of expression, and with the conceptual codes of art production.

That Delier gives his art talks for 5 TL can be read in the context of the “precariat”; it opens a small door for thinking about the artist’s precarity and the meaning of the artwork. The recordings of the talks in “Art Talks,” just like those in “Silence Performance” (2013), do not exist; the talks took place between the artist and the listener and stayed there -which is in fact a precarious situation. In the context of the accessibility of the artwork and the unique value of taking part in a performance, in terms of labor, time and one-to-one relation, this secrecy is worth thinking about, even though it is not an underlined and distinct theme, just as in the silence performance…

After the Gezi Park Resistance, many discussions took place on the relation between art and the street. Delier’s “Art Talks” performance is a meaningful form of action, quietly carried out, for looking again at the relation of art to the street… While it gives the feeling of feeding on the potential street encounters that the resistance started, it makes us remember the concept of “public dialogue,” which since Ancient Greece has been almost a determining element in the shaping of the city.