Bubbles of the Dying: Geography and Displacement, History and Erasure by Nikos Papastergiadis

Text by Nikos Papastergiadis

Arts, 2026, 15(4), 80 (This article belongs to the Special Issue Rethinking Art History and Culture: Defining an Ecological Approach)
Wars, migration and climate change are pressing down on us. The genocide in Gaza. War in Ukraine. These events are bringing news of unspeakable horrors at specific sites and inspiring racist outbursts across multiple fronts. The impact of climate change on the Global South and the rates of demographic decline in the Global North is generating unprecedented spirals of interdependency. The grotesque sight of suffering around the world leaves no one immune. Violence in one place is dredging forth traumatic memories from other places. This context has radical implications for the way we approach art and culture. Where do we stand on these issues? How does this impact the way we see images?
To rethink the ecological and geo-political crisis of our times, scholars in the humanities must first abandon the colonialist fantasy that there is a fixed standard and final vantage point from which the world of art can be surveyed. A new kind of intimate engagement is necessary. John Berger often contemplated the ways the surrounding infiltrates the interplay between perception and memory. He was conscious of the tension between the intellectual effort to organise thought through linear stages of development and the emotional work of radial association. Rather than representing memory as a belated construct of past experiences, Berger claimed that perception and memory occur simultaneously. In his collaboration with Jean Mohr in Another Way of Telling, he illustrated the looping form and simultaneous experience of memory in a long quotation from the memoir of a Palestinian author written in the early 1970s:
Never shall if forget Nadia’s leg, amputated from the top of the thigh. No! Nor shall I forget the grief which had moulded her face and merged into its traits for ever. I went out of the hospital in Gaza that day, my hand clutched in silent derision on the two pounds I had bought with me to give to Nadia. The blazing sun filled the streets with the colour of blood. And Gaza was brand new, Mustafa! You and I never saw it like this. The stones piled up at the beginning of the Shajiya quarter where lived had a meaning, and they seemed to have been put there for no other reason but to explain it. This Gaza in which we have lived and with whose good people we had spent seven years of defeat was something new. It seemed to me just a beginning. I didn’t know why I thought it was just a beginning. I imagined that the main street that I had walked along on the way back home was only the beginning of a long, long road leading to Safad. Everything in this Gaza throbbed with sadness which was not confined to weeping. It was a challenge; more than that, it was something like reclamation of the amputated leg. (Ghassan Kanafani, quoted in Berger and Mohr 1982, p. 117).
More recently, Michael Rothberg, in his pathbreaking book Multidirectional Memory (Rothberg 2009), also reminded us that memory does not sit still. It is shaped by local situations and driven onwards by transnational forces. It carries and embeds echoes from other sources. Its movement is a spiral form that is simultaneously cascading, gathering, and dropping elements. It is consolidated by alliances and expanded by connections. In short, memory is neither linear nor mono causal.
Reflecting on her own emergent status as an expert on French theory, Gayatri Spivak disavowed the conventional stance of authority (Spivak 2016). She did not see herself as the master surveyor, but rather as someone who had entered a field and could speak with it, not on it. This was a strategy she admired in the work of Jacques Derrida who held back on destroying that which he was deeply engaged in deconstructing. While responding to the request to ‘talk’ about her origin story, Spivak chose not to look back at the staging of her experiences with a critical distance. She deployed the stance of critical intimacy, a way of implicating herself as she teased out the threads that shaped her life (Spivak 1992).
I am leaning on Berger, Spivak and Rothberg to situate my own approach towards Pınar Öğrenci, an artist with whom I share much in common. I first witnessed Öğrenci’s work at documenta fifteen (18 June–25 September 2022). The controversy over antisemitism that shrouded that event obscured the aims of the directorial team and the effort of the various collectives. The broader attempt to inject an ecological approach into aesthetic experience and the articulation of a transnational perspective in curatorial bridge building were both seriously curtailed (Papastergiadis 2023, pp. 293–310; Papastergiadis 2024). The directorial team of documenta fifteen were part of an art collective from Indonesia called ruangrupa. They worked under two noble principles—devolve power by inviting collectives to invite other collectives, and to exercise the Indigenous eco-philosophy of lumbung on the widest possible scale. Lumbung is an Indonesian term that refers to the communal process of sharing resources, transmitting knowledge, and redistributing responsibility (ruangrupa and Papastergiadis 2021). I was invited to speak at the closing events. By then, many of the collaborative activities that had been initiated by the collectives had run their course. The documentation and traces that were left behind were suggestive. However, to fully grasp the impact of these projects, I am sure that you had to be there. This elevation of the ephemeral presents a challenge to the art historical imperative to judge the formal quality of an artwork. The sheer diversity of cultural reference points presents a further challenge to the lexicon of critical evaluation. Documenta had been transformed from being a display cabinet of finished artistic products to becoming akin to what Hakim Bey called The Temporary Autonomous Zone (Bey 2011). It was with these thoughts mulling once again in my head that I climbed the grand entrance to Hessiches Landemuseum in Kassel. Before I entered the first room, I could hear a familiar and enchanting melody. Behind the curtain in the main room, there was a projection of the film Aşît—The Avalance (2022) by Pınar Öğrenci. I will come back to discuss this film later in this article.
….
Please use the link above for the full text.